Trial & Error

Prologue: The Tragic Case of Holly Bobo

Welcome to the Trial & Error podcast, where seasoned criminal defense attorney Dana McLendon III, alongside co-host & forensic neuropsychologist Dr. Katie Spirko, take you on a deep dive into the tragic case of Holly Bobo, and the subsequent wrongful convictions of Zach Adams and his brother Dylan Adams. Holly Bobo’s disappearance in 2011 led to a high-profile investigation, bringing a national media spotlight on what was termed 'the most expensive, exhaustive investigation in the history of Tennessee'. Terry Britt was identified early on as a key suspect when he perfectly matched the physical description provided by the sole eye witness to Holly’s abduction, his alibi crumbled, and physical evidence linking Terry Britt to Holly was found at his home and in his vehicle. This crime also bore striking similarities to prior sexual assaults committed by Terry Britt; it was, indeed, right in line with his MO. An indictment seemed imminent. Then, in a plot twist no one with a solid working knowledge of the investigation could have predicted, the State abandoned it's interest in Terry Britt and returned its focus to 4 local ruffians who had already been conclusively ruled out as possible suspects when their alibis were thoroughly corroborated. Unwilling to let a lack of evidence stand in the way of mounting pressure to close the case, the State moved forward in 2017 in bringing Zach Adams to trial for the 2011 slaying of Holly Bobo. He was convicted by a jury despite a lack of any physical evidence linking him to the crime and substantial factual support for his claims of innocence. The State’s case rested almost entirely on the star witness testimony of co-defendant Jason Autry, who eventually recanted his entire story in an interview with Dr. Spirko, explaining in detail how and why he lied during the trial. Serious allegations of corruption and incompetence have been leveled against the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation and the Shelby County District Attorney's office for their handing of this case, including accusations of destroying evidence and yielding to political pressure for a conviction, regardless of the truth. Widespread speculation persists that Terry Britt is the true perpetrator, while he remains uncharged in connection with this gruesome crime.Our podcast offers exclusive insights, featuring interviews and direct audio footage from law enforcement officers who investigated the case and testified at trial, as well as first-hand accounts from the still imprisoned wrongfully convicted co-defendants, their families, and other key witnesses. We uncover crucial evidence that was never presented in court.

Episode 1: Unfinished Business w/ US Marshal John Walker (retd.)

In the heart-wrenching premiere episode of "Trial and Error," unfold the events of one of Tennessee's most baffling and grim mysteries: the disappearance and murder of 20 year old nursing student Holly Bobo. A serene morning in a small town is shattered, sparking an emotional six-year journey involving relentless law enforcement, a tightly-knit community's hopes and fears, and numerous suspects. Dive into the enthralling investigation that entangles veteran U.S. Marshal John Walker, who is determined to challenge the convictions and search for the true culprit.
Join us as we explore the savage impact of drugs on this rural community, the prominence of media scrutiny, and the poignant toll on Holly's family. Through gripping interviews and expert storytelling, follow the intricate pathways of cell tower data, witness accounts, and the shattering revelations of insiders willing to unveil hidden truths. Discover the tireless pursuit of justice that compels seasoned lawyer Dana McLendon III and forensic neuropsychologist Dr. Katie Spirko to delve deeper into the case, determined to shine a light on questionable verdicts marking the end, or perhaps just the beginning, of this quest for truth.

Episode 2: Train's a Comin' w/ Recanting Star Witness Jason Autry

Dr. Katie Spirko takes you behind the barbed wire fences of Shelby County Penal Farm, where she meets with co-defendant turned star witness for the State, Jason Autry. Now 8 years after the trial and with nothing to gain from changing his story, Jason Autry provides a detailed account of how and why he lied at Zach Adams's 2017 trial for the kidnapping, rape, and murder of Holly Bobo, including shocking allegations about who helped him construct the testimony that got Zach Adams convicted despite no physical evidence linking him to the crime.

Episode 3 (Part 1): Train the Witness - examining Jason Autry's trial testimony

Join us in Episode 3 of Trial and Error, as hosts Dana McLendon and Dr. Katie Spirko continue their deep dive into the haunting mystery of Holly Bobo's disappearance and murder. This episode brings you to a crucial point in the 2017 trial of Zach Adams, shedding light on the lone trial that sought justice for Holly. Discover how a contentious testimony from Jason Autry shaped the prosecution’s case but left many questions unanswered.
After a recap of the previous episodes—where we heard from U.S. Marshal John Walker and learned about the initial twists of a convoluted investigation—we delve into the heart of Autry's statements. Dr. Spirko guides us through the courtroom drama, examining the inconsistencies and unbelievable claims made under oath, all while trying to understand the motivations that could drive a man to lie in such a high-profile case.
We unravel the layers of truth and deceit surrounding Jason Autry's testimony, questioning the reliability of a witness caught between the pressures of legal battles and personal demons. As Autry paints scenes of murder and chaos, his narrative clashes against logical analysis and the physical evidence—or lack thereof. The pursuit of justice for Holly Bobo reveals not only a labyrinth of legal tactics but also a profound reflection on the human capacity for honesty and manipulation.
Tune in as we explore the delicate balance between truth and fiction in the Holly Bobo case, and what it means for justice in this harrowing saga. Don’t miss part two, where more revelations await.

Episode 3 (Part 2): Train the Witness - examining Jason Autry's trial testimony

In this gripping episode of 'Trial and Error,' we continue to delve deep into the controversial testimony of Jason Autry, whose words played a pivotal role in the trial of Zach Adams. Journey with us as we dissect the intricacies of Autry's narrative, the peculiar vocabulary choices that suggest coaching, and the implausibilities that cast doubt on his story.
As we unravel the details of a murder trial that captivated the nation, discover how Autry's testimony single-handedly introduced critical elements of kidnapping, rape, and murder charges against Zach Adams. His words, placing Adams at the scene and implicating others, appear meticulously crafted, leaving listeners to question the truth behind his declarations.
Join us as we explore alternative narratives, scrutinize law enforcement's investigation, and highlight the voices that claimed the real culprit was another man. This episode is a compelling examination of how one man's story swayed a jury and altered the course of justice.

Bonus Episode: Update on March 21, 2025 Court Hearing

In this bonus episode of the Trial and Error Podcast, co-host Dana McLendon III updates listeners on the recent March 21, 2025, hearing in Zach Adams's post-conviction relief petition. Please also check out our YouTube channel @TrialandErrorPodcast for a YouTube video update on this hearing with Dana and co-host Dr. Katie Spirko.